là
Donc il y a un australien qui connait très bien le Mirage III (peut-être ex-pilote) qui dit ça dans ce lien
(le 'conflict' est la guerre des Malouines)The R550 is/was a better close in Missile than the AIM9L. The R550 autoscan lock ability was awesome in comparison the AIM9L mechanisation in the Sea Harrier at the time of the conflict.
à côté de ça, il y a quelqu'un qui je crois est ex-pilote dans la HAF qui dit ça :
Qu'en pensez-vousWhen I served, HAF M2Ks bore the Magic II. The latter was indeed superior to the AIM-9L/M that HAF F-16s were packing - but only marginally, not drastically.
The Magic II had a more sensitive IR sensor which resulted in a somewhat quicker lock buzz signal than respectively the AIM-9L. Also, the sensor head had a greater angle of movement (+/- 10 degrees if I'm not mistaken) which resulted in a slightly greater forward lock cone. That, coupled with the MagicIIs great aerodynamic performance made it possible to score a Fox2 at slightly greater angles and shorter moments than with the AIM-9 series.
But like I said all the above constitute marginal differences. I find it hard to believe that the predecessor of the Magic II was already better than the Lima (it would mean no real improvement from Magic I to Magic II). Especially since I never saw it referred to as an "all aspect" IR missile anywhere, contrary to the AIM-9L.